Autonomy, Consent and the Law (Biomedical Law & Ethics by Sheila A.M. McLean

By Sheila A.M. McLean

Autonomy is frequently acknowledged to be the dominant moral precept in sleek bioethics, and it's also very important in legislations. admire for autonomy is related to underpin the legislation of consent, that is theoretically designed to guard the proper of sufferers to make judgements in response to their very own values and for his or her personal purposes. The proposal that consent underpins beneficent and lawful scientific intervention is deeply rooted within the jurisprudence of nations during the international. even though, Autonomy, Consent and the legislations demanding situations the connection among consent principles and autonomy, arguing that the very nature of the felony technique inhibits its skill to recognize autonomy, particularly in situations the place sufferers argue that their skill to behave autonomously has been decreased or denied end result of the withholding of knowledge which they might have desired to obtain. Sheila McLean additional argues that the bioethical debate in regards to the actual nature of autonomy – whereas wealthy and challenging – has had little if any impression at the legislation. utilizing the alleged contrast among the individualistic and the relational types of autonomy as a template, the writer proposes that, whereas it'd be assumed that the model ostensibly most popular by way of legislations – approximately corresponding to the individualistic version – will be transparently and continually utilized, in reality courts have vacillated among the 2 to accomplish policy-based pursuits. this is often highlighted through exam of 4 particular parts of the legislation which so much easily lend themselves to attention of the appliance of the autonomy precept: specifically refusal of life-sustaining therapy and assisted demise, maternal/foetal concerns, genetics and transplantation. This publication may be of significant curiosity to students of scientific legislations and bioethics.

Show description

Read Online or Download Autonomy, Consent and the Law (Biomedical Law & Ethics Library) PDF

Best health & medical law books

Human Tissue in Transplantation and Research: A Model Legal and Ethical Donation Framework

Deficiencies and shortfalls within the provide of human organs for transplantation and human tissue for examine generate coverage dilemmas the world over and feature frequently given upward push to significant and deleterious controversies, resembling these when it comes to organ and tissue retention practices following autopsy exam.

Contemporary Issues in Healthcare Law and Ethics

Modern matters in Healthcare legislation and Ethics, 3rd variation, examines an important felony and moral concerns in healthcare and offers crucial details to help you discover ways to establish and take on capability criminal difficulties.

The Social Security Answer Book

This new name is an equipped choice of genuine questions requested through participants from round the kingdom to Social safeguard merits specialist Stanley A. Tomkiel, III. The questions are derived from emails got from genuine humans asking real-life questions on numerous parts of shock for themselves and their kin.

Lebenserhaltung als Haftungsgrund

In der Arbeit wird untersucht, unter welchen Voraussetzungen die Erhaltung menschlichen Lebens Schadensersatzansprüche desjenigen begründet, der – einstweilig – am Leben erhalten wird. Diese möglicherweise befremdlich anmutende Fragestellung ergibt sich aus der Existenz des Patientenrechts auf Selbstbestimmung, das auch die Ablehnung lebenserhaltender Maßnahmen umfasst.

Additional resources for Autonomy, Consent and the Law (Biomedical Law & Ethics Library)

Sample text

127 This, however, does not entail abandonment of respect for individual autonomy nor does it require a wholesale endorsement of the relational account. Rather, while prioritising the rights of the individual it depends on the assumption (which I suggest is reasonable) that individual choices are seldom – if ever – made in the kind of vacuum abhorred by proponents of relational autonomy. Respect for individual(istic) autonomy also, as we have seen, does not and need not deny the legitimacy of other interests.

The international community, in commending member states to the facilitation and endorsement of the norms of human rights, specifically requires that attention is paid to the extent to which the individual’s autonomy is maximised in political, social (or professional) relationships. The very idea of autonomy, then, is inseparable in the modern 115 116 Report of the Select Committee on Medical Ethics, HL Paper 21–1, 1994, at p 7, para 4. Tauber, A I, ‘Sick Autonomy’, Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 46(4), (autumn), 2003: 484–95, at p 485.

Arguably, it should also be consistently applied so that patients can predict with some certainty the extent to which their decisions will be respected. It is, of course, potentially difficult for a set of general rules to address or even reflect the nuanced ethical debate on autonomy. Nonetheless, law is the vehicle that has the task of translating values like respect for autonomy into personal and societal reality. Before considering what the law actually does, it is worth reflecting on the way in which, if at all, the concept of consent co-exists with or supports autonomous choice, and on what basis.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.20 of 5 – based on 7 votes